847.501.2020

Mind•Eye Media:

Response to the Hallmark Channel Movie

As a loyal Hallmark Christmas movie viewer for the past 10 years and a practicing optometrist for more than 30 years, I was truly disappointed with the inappropriate and false nuances and references to optometrists in one of this holiday season’s Hallmark films – Write Before Christmas.

Unlike what the dialog suggests in the movie, optometrists are NOT “fake doctors.” They undergo many years of additional education after college, devoting themselves to earning a Doctor of Optometry degree and becoming licensed health professionals in the practice of eye care. Indeed, optometrists are trained and certified to conduct comprehensive eye examinations intended to identify, assess and address patients’ visual needs and problems, including many eyesight abnormalities. As primary care practitioners, they are able to diagnose brain tumors, heart disease and lung problems — even high blood pressure.

The comment in the film that optometrists attend “medical school” is incorrect as well. Optometrists attend colleges and institutes dedicated specifically to optometry.

Meanwhile, the script writer’s mishandled attempt to refer to optometrists with the comments – “He isn’t a doctor; he just fits bifocals” – is demeaning and just plain wrong. Optometrists do not “fit” eyeglasses; opticians do. Opticians are technical practitioners, who play a critical role in determining the necessary specifications of eyeglasses and other optometric appliances to ensure that they meet the strict requirements of the optometrist’s prescriptions for patients. However, opticians are not trained in the same way as are optometrists, who must undergo a four-to-five-year program following college graduation.

Frankly, I have enjoyed – and appreciated – the metamorphosis of the Hallmark channel as it has become more diversified in its casting and topics to reflect the overall changes in society generally and the channel’s many audiences specifically. Inclusion of Hanukkah as a theme and the assignment of more featured roles for women and minorities are examples of Hallmark’s social commitment. That’s why the pejorative “gag” of “fake doctor” in reference to optometrists and the disingenuous comments regarding opticians are seemingly so out-of-character – and unnecessary.

Unlike other Hallmark movies that have featured the “Fancy Suit Guy” and the “Handyman,” there was no need for a “Fake Doctor Guy.”

My hope is that Hallmark will take more care in the future to review – and, if possible, correct — movie dialog to ensure that it is not offensive to gender, to cultures, to the afflicted and to the many different workers and professionals who serve others daily.

Thank you for your attention.

Deborah Zelinsky OD

Executive Research Director and Founder

Mind-Eye Institute

Northbrook, Illinois

Take The 60 Second MindEye Brain Quiz

Mind-Eye Featured in the News Media

Newspapers and television stations throughout the country have been reporting on the work of the Mind-Eye Institute. Read the articles below to learn more about what the Mind-Eye Institute is doing to pioneer change in how optometric evaluations are performed in the 21st Century.

Mind-Eye Response to Article in The Atlantic

Mind•Eye Media: Mind-Eye Response to Article in The Atlantic Dear Editor: The November 27, 2019 article headlined, The Great American Eye-Exam Scam, actually perpetuates an outdated concept – that eyeglasses are merely appliances to enhance eyesight clarity. Nothing,...

Nothing ‘Puzzling’ About the Role of ‘Vision’ in Visionary

Mind•Eye Media: Nothing ‘Puzzling’ About the Role of ‘Vision’ in Visionary Do our newsletter readers recall the 1,000-piece Netherlands jigsaw puzzle I was putting together last month and that prompted me to consider all the visual skills needed to accomplish the...

Pastor’s Vertigo Gives Hope to Police Officer with PTSD

Mind•Eye Success Story: Pastor’s Vertigo Gives Hope to Police Officer with PTSD   Kyle Hein, Who Also Suffered Brain Injury, Finds Relief at Mind-EyeThe local church can be a source of hope. So, it was for Kyle Hein of Michigan, a former police officer who was first...

‘Hope for HIE’ Not Just the Name of a Facebook Group

Mind•Eye Media: ‘Hope for HIE’ Not Just the Name of a Facebook Group Mind-Eye’s Approaches Give Hope to Parents of Babies with Injured Brains “Hope for HIE.” It’s more than simply the name of a Facebook group for parents of infants with hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy...

Mind-Eye Response to Article in Indianapolis Star

Mind•Eye Media: Mind-Eye Response to Article in Indianapolis Star Dear Editor: The December 2 article by Shari Rudavsky concerning nearsightedness in children misses two critical points. First, eyeglasses are not primarily appliances for achieving 20/20 clarity, even...

Dr. Zelinsky Radio Interview on “Live with Rudi Bakhtiar”

Mind•Eye Media: Dr Zelinsky Radio Interview on “Live with Rudi Bakhtiar” Dr. Zelinsky was recently a guest on the live radio show “Live with Rudi Bakhtiar” on Los Angeles' KIRN 670 AM to discuss the advanced methods for assessing brain function with Neuro-Optometric...

Response to the Hallmark Channel Movie

Mind•Eye Media: Response to the Hallmark Channel Movie As a loyal Hallmark Christmas movie viewer for the past 10 years and a practicing optometrist for more than 30 years, I was truly disappointed with the inappropriate and false nuances and references to...

2019 Holiday Message From Mind-Eye President, Zemen Abebe

Mind•Eye Media: 2019 Holiday Message From Mind-Eye President:Zemen Abebe I would like to extend a heartfelt “THANK YOU” to all of you, our MEI team, for your hard work, dedication and support. As a mission-driven Institute with ​a campaign to provide advanced 21s​ t​...

Internet Signal on Beach Puts Him on Road to Recovery

Success Stories: Internet Signal on Beach Puts Him on Road to Recovery  Mind-Eye Institute Helps Return Brain-Injured Patient to Person He was “She is still in business,” Michael Warnecke’s wife, Alycia, yelled excitedly from the only point on the beach at Priest...

Nothing ‘Puzzling’ About It; ‘Vision’ More Than Just Eyesight

Mind•Eye Media: Nothing ‘Puzzling’ About It; ‘Vision’ More Than Just Eyesight   Jigsaw Pieces Prompt Reflection on Critical Role of Retinal Processing  What makes my new jigsaw puzzle from the Netherlands especially challenging is that the picture on the box cover...